Are Amazon Algorithm Bugs Killing Your Merch Dreams?

In partnership with

For Amazon Merch on Demand sellers, the goal is straightforward: upload a standout design and let the A10 algorithm carry it to success. But for some, the ride turns sour—listings disappear from search, impressions vanish, or rankings plummet without explanation. “Glitch!” they shout, pinning the blame on Amazon’s tech. Across X posts and Reddit threads, complaints about algorithmic hiccups disrupting Merch livelihoods are mounting. Is A10 a broken system derailing dreams, or are sellers dodging accountability for their own missteps? The glitch debate’s alive, and the Merch community’s split down the middle.

The frustration’s palpable. Sellers on Reddit report listings going dark—active in the dashboard but invisible in search, with impressions dropping to zero. One X user vented about a design tanking from a decent BSR to obscurity overnight, despite consistent sales. A Facebook group focused on Merch recently saw dozens of posts about “unindexed” listings or frozen sales, some resurfacing after days or weeks, others lost for good. The pattern’s familiar: a sudden, unexplained collapse, followed by cries of “bug!”

Concrete numbers are elusive—Amazon doesn’t publish A10’s quirks—but seller tools hint at trouble. Users of Helium 10 and AMZScout frequently note odd shifts: listings in niches like “cat mom” (thousands of monthly searches) slipping from early search pages to the back, with no clear trigger like keyword changes or sales dips. “It’s not competition—it’s a glitch,” one seller argued on X, claiming half their slots went “invisible.” Another posted a screenshot: an active listing, zero views, weeks on end.

Skeptics push back hard. “Glitches are just excuses,” a high-tier seller wrote on Reddit, pointing to their own stable catalog. Jungle Scout data shows the top tier of Merch sellers—often those with hundreds of listings—tend to hold stronger BSRs, rarely flagging tech issues. A recent Reddit poll asked if “glitches” resolved after tweaks like re-uploading or refining keywords—nearly half said yes, suggesting user error might outpace systemic flaws. “Blurry art or weak tags—people scream ‘bug’ when it’s on them,” one comment read.

The glitch side’s got some history, though. In 2024, Amazon acknowledged an indexing issue—listings stuck in “processing” for weeks—after seller uproar prompted a fix, as noted in community discussions. “If it’s happened before, it’s still out there,” one X user argued. Theories swirl: “A10’s testing updates—low tiers get hit hardest,” another speculated. No hard proof exists, but oddities persist—listings at lower tiers fading while higher-tier duplicates hold strong, same keywords, same niche.

The divide’s stark. If A10’s glitchy, it’s a wild card—zapping listings at random, leaving sellers scrambling. One camp swears by evidence: re-upload a “dead” design, and sales sometimes bounce back. The other side doubles down: refresh your approach—titles, keywords, images—and outpace the chaos. “Tech’s not flawless, but complainers lose,” an X post jabbed. Tools like Jungle Scout show most top designs stay steady—glitch or no glitch, execution matters.

A10’s a beast—buggy or not, it’s your arena. Glitches might strike, a shadow from Amazon’s vast machine, or they might mask your own fumbles. Sellers on X and Reddit wrestle both: vanishing listings spark fury, yet tweaks often revive them. Clone one of your designs, upload it fresh, and see—does it sink or soar? The algo doesn’t confess, but your results will. Step up or bow out—glitches don’t care, and neither does the game. What’s your take: tech’s fault, or the seller’s?

Unlock New Growth on Amazon

Growing on Amazon takes more than great products—it’s about getting in front of the right shoppers. With affiliate marketing, you can:

✅ Drive high-quality traffic – Reach shoppers off Amazon by partnering with 8K+ vetted publishers, affiliates, and influencers.
✅ Control your commissions – Set CPA or CPC by product or creator to maximize ROI.
✅ Boost organic rankings – Amazon rewards external traffic with better search visibility and a 10% kickback.

Download the Guide