Is Etsy’s AI-Powered Search Algorithm Killing Small POD Shops?

Etsy’s AI-driven search algorithm, increasingly used to curate collections and prioritize listings in 2025, is under fire for sidelining small print-on-demand (POD) shops. Machine learning now expands “hand-picked” collections, but small sellers accuse the system of favoring large shops with bigger ad budgets, eroding Etsy’s “Keep Commerce Human” ethos. With 95 million buyers, visibility is everything, yet new POD entrepreneurs struggle to rank against established players. For instance, a small shop selling personalized T-shirts might see its listings buried, while a high-spending competitor dominates search results for trending terms like “custom gift” (82,890 searches in March 2025, per eRank).

The controversy lies in fairness. Small sellers, already grappling with Etsy’s 6.5% transaction fees, feel squeezed out by an algorithm that seems to reward revenue over creativity. This pits Etsy’s profitability against its artisan roots, alienating the indie sellers who built its reputation. Critics argue that AI prioritization creates a pay-to-play system, with Etsy Ads (a $1.5 billion revenue stream in 2024) amplifying the gap. Yet, defenders claim AI is necessary to compete with Amazon and Temu, streamlining searches for buyers and boosting platform efficiency.

Is Etsy betraying its origins, or evolving to survive? The answer matters for POD shops, where margins are thin and visibility is survival. Actionable steps: Optimize listings with high-traffic keywords like “personalized necklace” to counter algorithmic bias. Test Etsy Ads with small budgets ($5/day) to gauge impact, but track ROI closely to avoid overspending. Join Etsy seller forums on X to advocate for transparent algorithm policies—collective pressure could spark change. Finally, diversify by listing on other platforms (and start your own Shopify store) to reduce reliance on Etsy’s unpredictable system.

Small POD sellers must adapt to this AI-driven reality while pushing Etsy to honor its roots. The algorithm isn’t going away, but strategic moves can keep your shop alive.

🚨 Want to become famous(er), grab more customers, and 100X your reach?

Stop burning budget on ads and hoping for clicks. Podcast listeners lean in, hang on every word, and buy from guests who deliver real value. But appearing on dozens of incredible podcasts overnight as a guest has been impossible to all but the most famous.

PodPitch.com is the NEW software that books you as a guest (over and over!) on the exact kind of podcasts you want to appear on – automatically.

⚡ Drop your LinkedIn URL into PodPitch.
🤖 Scans 4 Million Podcasts: PodPitch.com's engine crawls every active show to surface your perfect podcast matches in seconds.
🔄 Listens to them For You: PodPitch literally listens to podcasts for you to think about how to best get the host's attention for your targets.
📈 Writes Emails, Sends, And Follows Up Until Booked: PodPitch.com writes hyper-personalized pitches, sends them from your email address, and will keep following up until you're booked.

👉 Want to go on 7+ podcasts every month? Book a demo now and we'll show you what podcasts YOU can guest on ASAP:

Book Your Incredible Demo Now