Ten Merch Myths Debunked: Separating Fact from Fiction with Amazon Merch on Demand

In partnership with

Amazon Merch on Demand has sparked endless debates among creators, with wild rumors and half-truths swirling around like a digital wildfire. Is it a golden goose or a sinking ship? Does Amazon play favorites, or is it all just clever marketing smoke and mirrors? Buckle up as we shred ten of the spiciest myths and facts about this platform, delivering professional-grade clarity with a dash of controversy to keep things interesting. Let’s dive into the chaos and cut through the noise.

1. Tier Ups Are Selective, and Amazon Punishes Accounts at Whim

• Myth: Amazon handpicks who gets tiered up and smites accounts for no reason.

• Reality: Wrong. Tier progression hinges on sales numbers—hit the threshold, and you climb. The idea of Amazon playing puppet master with random punishments is a paranoid fantasy. Violations like copyright slips get you flagged, not secret vendettas. Data from seller forums and Amazon’s own guidelines back this up: it’s a merit game, not a favoritism fest.

2. Amazon Is Shutting Down Merch on Demand

• Myth: The platform’s days are numbered—Amazon’s pulling the plug any minute.

• Reality: Nope. This doomsday chatter flares up every time there’s a glitch or a slow season, but Merch is alive, kicking, and churning out huge profits. Hints at a shutdown are pure speculation from the tinfoil hat crowd. It’s still a cash cow.

3. Amazon Will Keep Adding More Products to Sell

• Fact: More products are indeed coming and are actively being tested by select beta sellers.

• Reality: True, and it’s a win worth celebrating. Amazon’s been expanding its POD catalog for years, giving creators more toys (and even shirt colors and sizes) to play with. Check the seller dashboard if you haven’t in a year or two —new products still happen (the most recent of which is the tumbler — a huge money maker), proving they’re doubling down, not dialing back.

4. The Algorithm Loves Old Listings and Reviews More Than SEO Wizardry

• Fact: Longevity and star power trump keyword stuffing.

• Reality: Seemingly true—and it’s a hot-button issue. Research shows older listings with solid reviews often outrank fresh SEO-optimized ones. Keywords matter, sure, but Amazon’s algorithm has a soft spot for proven performers. This rubs keyword junkies the wrong way, but the data doesn’t lie: patience and customer love weigh heavier than meta magic.

5. Merch Is a Set-It-and-Forget-It Cash Machine

• Myth: Upload a design, kick back, and watch the royalties roll in.

• Reality: Laughably false. This passive-income pipe dream crashes hard when you realize success demands fresh designs, trend-chasing, and promo hustle. Amazon handles printing, but you’re the engine. Sellers who treat it like a slot machine end up broke—controversial only because lazy hopefuls still buy the hype. It’s work, not witchcraft.

6. It’s a Get-Rich-Quick Goldmine

• Myth: Millionaire status awaits in weeks.

• Reality: Dead wrong. The “overnight success” stories are outliers or flat-out lies. Most grind for months—sometimes years—before seeing real cash. This myth fuels the hype train, but the truth is gritty: it’s a marathon, not a sprint. Controversy? Plenty—call out the gurus peddling this nonsense, and watch the sparks fly.

7. Approval Is a Breeze, Anyone Can Join

• Myth: Sign up today, sell tomorrow—easy peasy.

• Reality: False, and it’s a rude awakening. Amazon’s approval process is a gauntlet—vague rejections and long waits weed out the casuals. It’s a gatekeeper move, not an open invite. Some cry elitism, others say it keeps quality high. Either way, it’s not the free-for-all newbies expect.

8. More Designs Equals More Money, No Effort Needed

• Myth: Flood the platform with uploads and profit explodes.

• Reality: Not even close. Quantity without quality or marketing is a recipe for crickets. Successful sellers pinpoint niches and push their listings—spamming designs just clogs your dashboard. This myth irks pros who know the game, while rookies cling to it like a lifeline. Spoiler: it’s a sinking ship.

9. Only Big Shots Thrive—Newbies Are Doomed

• Myth: The platform’s too crowded; latecomers can’t win.

• Reality: False, and it’s a tired excuse. With billions of Amazon shoppers, niches are endless if you’ve got creativity and grit. Sure, competition’s fierce, but saturation’s a cop-out—new sellers break through daily. The controversy? Veterans scoff at whiners, while fresh faces prove the doubters wrong.

10. Copyrighted Stuff Flies Under the Radar

• Myth: Sneak in some pop culture riffs—Amazon won’t care.

• Reality: Dead wrong and dangerous. Upload a copyrighted design, and you’re begging for a ban. Amazon’s bots and legal eagles don’t mess around—fair use excuses won’t save you. This myth keeps the drama alive: risk-takers get burned, then scream foul. Play it safe, or pay the price.

Conclusion: Truth Burns Brighter Than Hype

Amazon Merch on Demand isn’t a mythical beast—it’s a real platform with real rules, rewards, and pitfalls. These ten debunked myths and confirmed facts peel back the curtain on a game that’s less about luck and more about strategy. Controversy swirls because everyone wants a shortcut, but the truth is spicier: success comes to those who work the system, not wish on it. So, ditch the fairy tales, roll up your sleeves, and make Merch your battlefield—because the only thing shutting down here is the nonsense.

Increase Your Amazon Position Today

What do brands like Magic Spoon, Unilever, and Farmacy all have in common? They’re using Stack Influence to get to the #1 page positioning on Amazon and increase their monthly revenue. With Stack Influence, you can improve your Amazon search positioning while also:

• Boosting up review rate

• Paying influencers with only products (stop negotiating fees)

• Generating real UGC (full rights image/video)

• Building brand awareness

• Completely automating the process

Get 10% OFF Today!